Metaskepticism: Meditations in Ethno-Epistemology
نویسندگان
چکیده
Throughout the 20 century, an enormous amount of intellectual fuel was spent debating the merits of a class of skeptical arguments which purport to show that knowledge of the external world is not possible. These arguments, whose origins can be traced back to Descartes, played an important role in the work of some of the leading philosophers of the 20 century, including Russell, Moore and Wittgenstein, and they continue to engage the interest of contemporary philosophers. (e.g., Cohen 1999, DeRose 1995, Hill 1996, Klein 1981, Lewis 1996, McGinn 1993, Nozick 1981, Schiffer 1996, Unger 1975, Williams 1996) Typically, these arguments make use of one or more premises which the philosophers proposing them take to be intuitively obvious. Beyond an appeal to intuition, little or no defense is offered, and in many cases it is hard to see what else could be said in support of these premises. A number of authors have suggested that the intuitions undergirding these skeptical arguments are universal – shared by everyone (or almost everyone) who thinks reflectively about knowledge. In this paper we will offer some evidence indicating that they are far from universal. Rather, the evidence suggests that many of the intuitions epistemologists invoke vary with the cultural background, socioeconomic status and educational background of the person offering the intuition. And this, we will argue, is bad news for the skeptical arguments that rely on those intuitions. The evidence may also be bad news for skepticism itself – not because it shows that skepticism is false, but rather because, if we accept one prominent account of the link between epistemic intuitions and epistemic concepts, it indicates that skepticism may be much less interesting and much less worrisome than philosophers have taken it to be.
منابع مشابه
Can Meditation Amend Your Brain? Rising Thoughts in Neuroscience of Meditation
Meditation is becoming increasingly popular as a topic for scientific research and are being increasingly used for stress, psychological well being, coping with chronic illness as well as adjunctive treatments for psychiatric disorders. Research suggests that these meditations have differential, dissociable effects on a wide range of cognitive (control) processes, such as attentional selection,...
متن کاملFocused attention, open monitoring and automatic self-transcending: Categories to organize meditations from Vedic, Buddhist and Chinese traditions.
This paper proposes a third meditation-category--automatic self-transcending--to extend the dichotomy of focused attention and open monitoring proposed by Lutz. Automatic self-transcending includes techniques designed to transcend their own activity. This contrasts with focused attention, which keeps attention focused on an object; and open monitoring, which keeps attention involved in the moni...
متن کاملWalking. Sensing. Participation: Three Meditations for Experiential Computing
This paper uses three meditations to contemplate walking, sensing and participation as three ways with which we can extend the notion of 'experiential computing' proposed by Yoo (2010). By using the form of meditations, loosely associated concepts that are part introspective and part 'causative', i.e. aimed as some form of change in perspective within Information Systems Research, the paper wea...
متن کاملMeditations in Ethno-epistemology1
5 For related discussion, see Brueckner (1999) and BruCckner (2001). 6 See, again, the papers in Ludlow and Martin for discussion of this point. 7 See Bmeckner (1998) and (1986a) and Wright (1992b) for other versions of the objection. 8 For further discussion of the 'question-begging' objection, see Brueckner (1992a) and (1996). 9 Here I am indebted to an unpublished paper by Byeong-uk Yi, 'Ske...
متن کامل